Pod brewing is ideal for decaf coffee. Most decaf drinkers only need one cup at a time and the strength of the coffee usually isn’t as important since caffeine isn’t a factor. All of that is right up a K-Cup’s alley.
With so many brands to choose from, 2.0 or 1.0 pods and more, making a choice can be difficult. We’ll guide you throughout the best tasting decaf coffee for Keurig coffee makers.
After looking at all the choices, I really like Chock Full o’Nuts Midtown Decaf, with its full, rich flavor that is unique and tasty. It has all the strong flavor of a fresh-brewed diner coffee, coming from a non-plastic mesh coffee pod that is kinder to the environment.
1. San Francisco Bay One Cup Decaf French Roast
This dark, rich coffee is a Dark French roast. That means the beans are roasted for a long time until the oils come to the surface. This makes for a deep, smoky flavor that is very bold. Yet there is minimal bitterness and it’s a very smooth brew.
The beans for SF Bay OneCup Decaf French Roast come from Central and South America; they are high-quality Arabica beans.
These coffee pods work with most Keurig and pod-based brewers. But what makes these OneCups unique is that they aren’t your average plastic pod. Instead, they have a mesh filter bag with a foil topper. The whole thing is even compostable.
One drawback of this design is that some of the newer, more powerful Keurig 2.0 brewers might make the mesh pods burst open in the machine. It works best and makes the strongest flavored cup of coffee when brewed at a smaller size, ideally six ounces.
If you like a strong flavor to your decaf, then this will work for you. Those looking for a milder, sweeter flavor won’t like this smoky dark roast.
2. Decaf Death By Chocolate Single Serve Cups
These medium roast Arabica beans have been decaffeinated and steeped in chocolate flavor. The chocolate flavors are both natural and artificial. There’s no added sugar, no lactose, and no gluten.
As far as flavor goes, it’s a double dose of actual flavor and chocolate aroma. The result is a deep chocolate flavor, which the medium-roasted beans really enhance.
Since there’s no sugar, you get the richness of chocolate without the sweetness. If you do add a sweetener and some type of milk or cream, the result is a cafe mocha-esque cup of joe.
The coffee pods are fully recyclable. These pods, although the same size, contain 35% more coffee than the Keurig pods. They have ridged sides instead of smooth, and the plastic is softer.
Those on strict diets will love the flavor of a rich, chocolate coffee drink without all the sugar and carbs. But those with sensitive taste buds might not like the artificial coffee flavor.
3. Pier 3 Light Roast Decaf Coffee Pods
This lighter, breakfast-appropriate coffee pod uses Arabica beans. They are slow roasted in small, craft batches for the best flavor. Since this is a light roast, the beans aren’t roasted for as long.
The result is a sweet, mild coffee taste, great for those who don’t like the deep, bitter flavor of dark coffee. These beans give a warm, rich taste, even for a light and decaf coffee. It’s one of the bolder light roasts available.
This coffee has nothing added to it; there are no additives, flavorings, sugars, or artificial ingredients of any kind. That means your cup of coffee won’t have any strange aftertastes. It’s certified Kosher as well.
The pod style of these coffee pods is good, but not great. The plastic is thin and flexible, which sometimes results in a collapsed bottom and lots of spilled grounds. However, most Keurig users find these work well for the majority of the time, and they come at a good price.
If you want a cup of coffee without cream, sugar, or flavorings, give this light roast decaf a try. It is much more pleasant to drink dark, which is perfect for those on low carb or keto diets.
4. Chock Full o’Nuts Midtown Decaf Medium Roast
Chock Full o’Nuts is notorious for being strong and bold; their decaf variety is no exception. There are 100% premium Arabica beans hand-selected from Colombia used in this coffee.
They are roasted to a medium level and then ground fresh and placed into pods. This medium roast has a full, bold flavor and nutty aroma. The acid is minimal and the finish is smooth, with no metallic notes.
These coffee pods aren’t the traditional plastic cups. Instead, they have a foil top and a filter bottom, with the grounds inside. The pods are in a resealable bag for freshness.
Related | Do K-Cups Expire?
The result is a stronger cup of coffee that is darker with more flavor. Although this is a decaf blend, it has the same flavor as a regular cup of coffee and is not weak or watery in the least.
The pods use 30% less plastic and are environmentally friendly. They are also compatible with all Keurig brewers, including the 2.0 models.
If you are a coffee flavor snob and hate the watery taste of many pod coffees, then you will love Chock Full o”Nuts; it’s a decaf with a fully caffeinated flavor.
5. McCafe Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods
Like most popular coffees, McCafe is made from Arabica beans. This premium roast is a medium roast, which strikes a good balance between mild sweetness and dark smokiness.
If you have a sensitive tongue, you may notice some bitterness at the end, with an almost metallic aftertaste.
These are traditional K-Cup style pods. All plastic with coffee inside, the result is sometimes weaker than many drinkers desire. This is brewed best in a smaller size with a strong setting for the best flavor.
One thing to note: while this is the same coffee that’s brewed in McDonald’s restaurants, it just doesn’t have the same flavor because it isn’t drip brewed. If you are looking to replicate a McDonald’s coffee at home, you may be disappointed in this shadow of the original.
This is a good, basic cup of coffee with a balanced flavor. It’s also one of the most affordable options out there. Coffee connoisseurs may scoff at the taste, but those who want a reliable cup of decaf will not be disappointed in this consistent option.
6. Peet’s Coffee Decaf House Blend Dark Roast
Something that makes Peet’s coffee special is that each batch is hand roasted by a few experienced roasters. Because of this level of control, the House Blend gets the perfectly dark roast to really extract the most flavor from the bean.
The beans come from rich, volcanic soil in South America. They have a bright and sharp taste, and although they’re roasted dark, they have a medium body that isn’t as strong as some darker French roasts. They have solid flavor and aroma, despite being decaffeinated beans.
These are Keurig brand K-Cup pods. That means that they are guaranteed to work in all Keurig machines, but the plastic pods will work in most pod coffee brewers.
There’s more coffee inside these pods than most, and the super finely ground coffee and mesh filter help you get a relatively strong cup of coffee.
This coffee is not bitter and has a great flavor. It is on the pricier end of the spectrum, but you really will get what you pay for. This is truly a great cup for hard-core coffee fans and necessity drinkers alike.
7. Tayst Decaf Coffee Pods – Defiantly Decaf
Nope, that’s not a typo. This coffee is definitely decaffeinated, but it defies all taste expectations! This water-process decaf is roasted dark, so it has a very rich flavor. It tastes just like a rich cup of full, dark roast regular coffee.
There are minimal bitter notes and the deep smokiness is preserved, even in the pod brewers.
The Tayst Purpod 100 is totally compostable – the top, mesh filter, and all. That’s because it’s all made from biomaterials.
The fact that these pods have a mesh filter means that they brew wonderful coffee, but they may not work in all Keurig coffee makers.
These Purpods and coffee beans are also Rainforest Alliance Certified. If you are eco-conscious but want the convenience of coffee pods, then this is certainly the coffee for you!
This small company has big flavor. Each box comes with a handwritten note and a guarantee that you’ll love the flavor. It’s more pricey than cheap grocery store brands, but the flavor is worth it. Perfect for a flavorful evening coffee, it even holds up well with cream and sugar.
K-Cups are so quick and convenient. Unfortunately, they sometimes make watery coffee, and decaf is often the worst culprit. However, we have found the best decaf K-Cups for your brewing pleasure.
No matter your coffee consumption level – coffee snob or occasional drinker – Chock Full o’Nuts Midtown Decaf Medium Roast is sure to delight your taste buds with its balanced yet strong flavor.
The eco-friendly, strong brewing mesh filter pods are a plus. The price is just right: not cheap, yet not terribly expensive.
Pick any coffee on this list and enjoy a delicious cup of coffee any time of day!